SOUTH BEND, Ind. – In a match that showcased the resilience and determination of the Indiana Hoosiers, the team faced a formidable opponent in Notre Dame during the first round of the College Football Playoff. Coach Curt Cignetti, who engineered the greatest single-season turnaround in college football history, had his team end the season with a heart-wrenching 27-17 defeat.
Despite the loss, Indiana, ranked No. 10, made significant strides this season, proving their abilities against some of the nation’s best teams. In this decisive playoff game, however, talent disparities were evident as No. 7 Notre Dame capitalized on key moments.
“On big stages, the biggest stars tend to shine the brightest,” noted Cignetti. This sentiment rang true as players like Notre Dame’s Maxwell Award-winning quarterback Michael Penix Jr. showcased their skills, further highlighting the talent gap. Notre Dame’s roster boasts an impressive 57 four-star players, compared to Indiana’s 10, and one five-star player to Indiana’s none.

Curt Cignetti shows frustration during Notre Dame’s win over Indiana on Dec. 20, 2024. (HN photo/Jaren Himelick)
Throughout the game, Notre Dame displayed superior offensive capability, accumulating 394 total yards against Indiana’s 278. Indiana struggled on both ends, averaging only 2.3 yards per rush compared to Notre Dame’s 5.5 yards.
“They’re not the biggest group,” Indiana center Mike Katic remarked. “But they’re twitchy and fast.” This speed and agility allowed the Irish to dominate the field, leading 27-3 before Indiana scored a couple of late touchdowns.
James Carpenter, a standout on the Indiana defense, encountered a mix of good and bad moments. An early deflection set up a brief opportunity for Indiana, but a personal foul penalty later on diminished that chance. Carpenter reflected, “It was disappointing. I can’t be doing that. It was full speed, kind of bang, bang play, but as a senior leader I can’t be doing that.”
Despite the challenges, Carpenter finished his game with impressive statistics, contributing significantly to Indiana’s defensive efforts with seven tackles and blocking a field goal attempt.
Cignetti remained proud of his team’s journey, stating, “Look at the track that Indiana was on before we got here. Now, it’s a complete 180. I expect to be right back here next year.” As Indiana looks to the future, enhancing their recruiting efforts will be vital to achieving further success in competitive college football.
As this season comes to a close, the unwavering spirit of Indiana football remains intact. “This program’s only going up. Coach Cig is just getting started here. He’s going to get it done,” Carpenter concluded, embodying the optimism that resonates within the team.


